Beach Report Card section(new window) 2003-2004 Annual Beach Report Card
May 26, 2004
Table of Contents
Cover Page
Executive Summary
Introduction
About the Beach
Report Card
2003-2004 Analyses
Beach Pollution
Patterns
Del Norte
Humboldt
Mendocino
Sonoma
Marin
San Francisco
San Mateo
Santa Cruz
Monterey
San Luis Obispo
Santa Barbara
Ventura
Los Angeles
Orange
San Diego
State Legislation
Accomplishments &
Recommendations
Appendix A:
Thresholds-Grading
Appendix B:
Printable Report
Appendix C:
Acknowledgements
San Diego County
Analysis   |   Grades

There are six agencies within San Diego County that provided monitoring information to Heal the Bay's Beach Report Card: the City of Oceanside, the City of San Diego, Encina Wastewater Authority, San Elijo Joint Powers Authority, the San Onofre Generating Station, and the County of San Diego Environmental Health Services. A majority of the 100 monitoring locations covered by the Beach Report Card are sampled and analyzed by the City and County of San Diego. Samples are generally collected at the wave wash (where runoff and ocean water mix) or 25 yards away from a flowing storm drain, creek or river. For additional water quality information visit the San Diego County Environmental Health Services website.

San Onofre Beach, San Onofre Creek. Photo: Heal the Bay
San Onofre State Beach. Photo: Heal the Bay

Dry weather water quality at beaches in San Diego County was very good between April and October. Of the 100 water quality monitoring locations, 89% received goodto-excellent water quality marks (see Table 31 and Table 32). San Diego County had stretches of beaches with excellent water quality, such as San Onofre State Beach at San Mateo Creek all the way to La Jolla at Ravina (excluding beaches at river and creek outlets); Pacific Beach at Crystal Pier to Mission Beach, projection of Capistrano Place; Ocean Beach at Ocean Pier to Point Loma Lighthouse; and Coronado at North Beach to Imperial Beach at the south end. Within Mission and San Diego Bays, for the fourth year in a row, water quality varied greatly from beach to beach, making it difficult to recommend swimming locations. Beaches located within enclosed bays tend to have reduced tidal circulation and are more susceptible to long-term pollution problems compared to open ocean beaches. Only 72% of beaches within the bays received good-to-excellent water quality marks, compared to the 100% of open ocean beaches in San Diego County during the AB411 (April through October) time period.

There were 11 locations in San Diego County that received fair-to-poor water quality marks from April to October. The beaches in Mission and San Diego Bay accounted for nearly all of the poor grades. Other San Diego problem beaches for the summer of 2003 were: San Luis Rey River outlet in Oceanside, Pacific Beach at Pacific Beach Point, Ocean Beach at the San Diego River (Dog Beach) and the north side of Border Fence at Border Field State Park.

San Luis RIver, Oceanside. Photo: Heal the Bay
San Luis RIver, Oceanside. Photo: Heal the Bay

As is customary every November 1, the County of San Diego's Department of Environmental Health reduces its beach water quality monitoring to a handful of sites. However, this past year was slightly different because the County was able to extend their monitoring program to 12 popular surfing and swimming spots throughout the year. We commend the Department of Environmental Health for taking this step. The additional beaches sampled yearround include: Oceanside Beach at San Luis Rey River, Carlsbad State Beach at Tamarack (Agua Hedionda Lagoon), South Carlsbad State Beach at Batiquitos Lagoon, Del Mar City Beach at San Dieguito River, Torrey Pines State Beach at Los Peñasquitos Lagoon, Ocean Beach at San Diego River (Dog Beach), and Imperial Beach Pier. Beaches in San Onofre, Encinitas, La Jolla, Mission Bay, and San Diego Bay remained mostly untested during the winter months. Until year-round data is available, during non-summer months you will be swimming at these beaches at your own risk.

Given that the County of San Diego still reduces their monitoring program during the wet season, there were only 35 locations monitored during wet weather. A majority of the problem beaches were in the southern part of the County. Monitoring locations from Coronado Municipal Beach at Silver Strand to the Tijuana river mouth all received F grades.

Please see Table 33 for a brief review of dry weather water quality trends for San Diego County beaches for the past three years during AB411 (April to October). This year's water quality was slightly improved relative to the three-year average, with a substantial percentage increase in As. San Diego also received less rain this year, which is most likely reflected in this year's improved wet weather water quality percentages.

Clean Beach Initiative Summary
Funded with $7.8 million from the CBI program, there were five projects proposed to reduce bacterial pollution at local beaches in San Diego County. The City of San Diego has constructed a number of diversion and source abatement projects in Mission Bay. In addition, the City of San Diego has finished a source identification study, and based on results from this study is planning to implement irrigation control systems for all the parks within Mission Bay to help reduce over-watering and dry weather nuisance flows. Originally, the City was going to implement a major water circulation improvement project in Eastern Mission Bay, but they could not complete the environmental review in time for State Water Board approval. The City of Encinitas has successfully installed an ultraviolet/ ozone treatment facility at Moonlight Beach (Cottonwood Creek) to reduce the bacterial pollution in the creek before discharging it back into the lagoon and out to the ocean. Two of the three projects associated with the City of Imperial Beach have been implemented. A diversion project at Date Avenue will be constructed in the coming year, and an analysis by the Scripps Institute will be out sometime in the fall, and will include an analysis of coastal currents to determine the relationship between ocean currents (flow direction) from the Tijuana River, and magnitude and frequency of bacterial exceedances. The City and County of San Diego have partnered on a project for Ocean Beach (Dog Beach) in the San Diego River watershed. They have completed a source identification study, and are in the design process of replacing or rehabilitating a number of antiquated storm drains to protect existing dry weather diversions.

Sewage Spill Summary
The County of San Diego led most counties in the total number of sewage spills that triggered beach closures and the entire state in the total volume of sewage spilled. There were 37 sewage spills that caused beach closures, which was four more than last year. The total known volume discharged from these spills was approximately 7,004,325 gallons, which was about 4 million gallons less than the previous year. Overall, there were seven major spills (> 10,000 gallons), 19 minor spills, and 11 unknown volume amount spills that impacted San Diego County beaches. Roughly 99%, or 6,981,780 gallons of the total spill volume came from the seven major spills, the largest discharging over 4.6 million gallons in San Diego Bay at Tidelands Park. Areas with four or more spills with known volume amounts (this excludes the unknown volume amounts from the Tijuana River that often impact Imperial and Coronado Beaches) included Moonlight Beach, and Torrey Pines State Beach.

Go to the top of this page  This page :: Top
Go to the previous section  Previous section :: Orange County
Go to the next section  Next section :: State Legislation
County "Beach Bummers"
•  Pacific Beach Point*
Pacific Beach
•  Bonita Cove (north cove)
Mission Bay
•  Santa Clara Cove
Mission Bay
The above list (ordered N to S) represents the worst San Diego County beaches based on dry weather water quality. Click beach name for annual grades.
* = This site is also a CA "Beach Bummer" (see Executive Summary for complete state list)
Tables 31 & 32
Table 33
San Diego County - Analysis
2003-2004 Annual Beach Report Card


Copyright © 2004 Heal the Bay. All rights reserved.
The fishbones logo is a trademark of Heal the Bay.
The Beach Report Card® is a registered servicemark of Heal the Bay.